Methodology
Heat pump savings — methodology
The exact formulas, assumptions, default values and limitations behind the heat pump savings, payback and CO₂ calculator.
Last updated
This documents the Heat Pump Savings Calculator.
What this calculator does
It compares the cost to run an air-source heat pump against your current heating system — gas furnace, oil boiler or electric resistance — sized so both deliver the same useful heat each year. It estimates your annual running-cost saving, an optional payback if you supply a net install cost, and the CO₂ you'd cut.
The formulas
Annual running cost
current_fuel_kwh = annual_heat_demand_kwh / current_efficiency
current_heating_cost = current_fuel_kwh * current_fuel_price_per_kwh
heat_pump_kwh = annual_heat_demand_kwh / heat_pump_scop
heat_pump_cost = heat_pump_kwh * electricity_price_per_kwh
annual_saving = current_heating_cost - heat_pump_cost
Both systems deliver the same annual_heat_demand_kwh. The current system burns
more energy than the heat it delivers (efficiency below 1, or exactly 1 for
electric resistance), while the heat pump draws less electricity than the heat
it delivers (SCOP above 1).
Emissions
co2_current = current_fuel_kwh * current_fuel_co2_per_kwh
co2_heat_pump = heat_pump_kwh * grid_co2_per_kwh
co2_saved = co2_current - co2_heat_pump
Payback (only when a net install cost is entered)
payback_years = net_install_cost / annual_saving
We guard the division: with no install cost there is nothing to pay back; if the heat pump costs more to run, the install never pays back on running cost alone and we report that honestly rather than showing a misleading number. A zero SCOP or zero efficiency yields “no result” rather than infinity.
Default values
Every default below is editable in the calculator and shown with its source in the calculator’s assumptions table.
- Heat pump SCOP 3.2 — a mid-range seasonal figure for a modern air-source unit (typical 2.5–4.0).
- Current fuel price $0.05/kWh — a representative natural-gas price per kWh of fuel energy. Gas is sold per therm, so this is a conversion — always replace it with your own.
- Current fuel emissions 0.18 kg CO₂/kWh — natural gas combustion per kWh of fuel energy.
- Electricity price $0.17/kWh and grid carbon intensity 0.39 kg CO₂/kWh — US representative averages.
Limitations — read these
- SCOP is seasonal and drops in the cold. Efficiency falls sharply in very cold weather. We use one fixed seasonal figure; if you live in a harsh climate, lower the SCOP to stay realistic. - Fuel price per kWh is converted/representative. Gas (and oil) are sold per therm or litre, not per kWh of fuel. The default is a conversion — enter your own rate from a recent bill. - Excludes maintenance and backup heat. We compare running cost and CO₂ only. Servicing, and any electric-resistance backup used on the coldest days, are not modelled. - Average emission factors. Both the grid and the gas emission factors are averages; your local grid and fuel may differ, which changes the CO₂ result.
How we keep it honest
The calculation logic lives in a small, pure function that is unit-tested against normal, edge and invalid inputs (for example, a zero SCOP returns “no result” rather than infinity). If you spot an error, tell us and we’ll fix it.
Sources
Every default in this calculator traces to one of these.
- Heat pump systems — efficiency guidanceU.S. Department of Energy (energy.gov) · retrievedModern air-source heat pumps typically deliver a seasonal COP of roughly 2.5–4.0.
- Natural gas prices delivered to residential consumersU.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) · retrievedRoughly $0.04–0.06 per kWh of gas energy once converted from $/therm; varies by region and season.
- GHG Emission Factors Hub — stationary combustion (natural gas, fuel oil)U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) · retrievedNatural gas combustion ≈ 0.18 kg CO₂/kWh of fuel energy; heating oil is higher.
- Average price of electricity to ultimate customers (residential)U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) · retrievedResidential prices vary by state and change monthly. Treat the default as representative and edit to your own rate.
- eGRID U.S. annual average CO₂ output emission rate for delivered electricityU.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), eGRID · retrievedGrid carbon intensity varies widely by region; the default is the U.S. national average.
By EnergyTally Team · Editorial & analysis team
- Published
- Updated
- Review
- EnergyTally Team,